DNA methylation in Dictyostelium discoideum

DNA methyltransferases of type Dnmt2 are a highly conserved protein family with enigmatic function. The aim of this work was to characterize DnmA, the Dnmt2 methyltransferase in Dictyostelium discoideum, and further to investigate its implication in DNA methylation and transcriptional gene silencing. The genome of the social amoeba Dictyostelium encodes DnmA as the sole DNA methyltransferase. The enzyme bears all ten characteristic DNA methyltransferase motifs in its catalytic domain. The DnmA mRNA was found by RT-PCR to be expressed during vegetative growth and down regulated during development. Investigations using fluorescence microscopy showed that both DnmA-myc and DnmA-GFP fusions predominantly localised to the nucleus. The function of DnmA remained initially unclear, but later experiment revealed that the enzyme is an active DNA methyltransferase responsible for all DNA (cytosine) methylation in Dictyostelium. Neither in gel retardation assays, nor by the yeast two hybrid system, clues on the functionality of DnmA could be obtained. However, immunological detection of the methylation mark with an α - 5mC antibody gave initial evidence that the DNA of Dictyostelium was methylated. Furthermore, addition of 5-aza-cytidine as demethylating agent to the Dictyostelium medium and subsequent in vitro incubation of the DNA isolated from these cells with recombinant DnmA showed that the enzyme binds slightly better to this target DNA. In order to investigate further the function of the protein, a gene knock-out for dnmA was generated. The gene was successfully disrupted by homologous recombination, the knock-out strain, however, did not show any obvious phenotype under normal laboratory conditions. To identify specific target sequences for DNA methylation, a microarray analysis was carried out. Setting a threshold of at least 1.5 fold for differences in the strength of gene expression, several such genes in the knock-out strain were chosen for further investigation. Among the up-regulated genes were the ESTs representing the gag and the RT genes respectively of the retrotransposon skipper. In addition Northern blot analysis confirmed the up-regulation of skipper in the DnmA knock-out strain. Bisufite treatment and sequencing of specific DNA stretches from skipper revealed that DnmA is responsible for methylation of mostly asymmetric cytosines. Together with skipper, DIRS-1 retrotransposon was found later also to be methylated but was not present on the microarray. Furthermore, skipper transcription was also up-regulated in strains that had genes disrupted encoding components of the RNA interference pathway. In contrast, DIRS 1 expression was not affected by a loss of DnmA but was strongly increased in the strain that had the RNA directed RNA polymerase gene rrpC disrupted. Strains generated by propagating the usual wild type Ax2 and the DnmA knock-out cells over 16 rounds in development were analyzed for transposon activity. Northern blot analysis revealed activation for skipper expression, but not for DIRS-1. A large number of siRNAs were found to be correspondent to the DIRS-1 sequence, suggesting concerted regulation of DIRS-1 expression by RNAi and DNA methylation. In contrast, no siRNAs corresponding to the standard skipper element were found. The data show that DNA methylation plays a crucial role in epigenetic gene regulation in Dictyostelium and that different, partially overlapping mechanisms control transposon silencing for skipper and DIRS-1. To elucidate the mechanism of targeting the protein to particular genes in the Dictyostelium genome, some more genes which were up-regulated in the DnmA knock-out strain were analyzed by bisulfite sequencing. The chosen genes are involved in the multidrug response in other species, but their function in Dictyostelium is uncertain. Bisulfite data showed that two of these genes were methylated at asymmetrical C-residues in the wild type, but not in DnmA knock-out cells. This suggested that DNA methylation in Dictyostelium is involved not only in transposon regulation but also in transcriptional silencing of specific genes.

On the function of the Dictyostelium Argonaute A protein (AgnA) in epigenetic gene regulation

With molecular biology methods and bioinformatics, the Argonaute proteins in Dictyostelium discoideum were characterized, and the function of the AgnA protein in RNAi and DNA methylation was investigated, as well as cellular features. Also interaction partners of the PAZ-Piwi domain of AgnA (PAZ-PiwiAgnA) were discovered. The Dictyostelium genome encodes five Argonaute proteins, termed AgnA/B/C/D/E. The expression level of Argonaute proteins was AgnB/D/E > AgnA > AgnC. All these proteins contain the characteristic conserved of PAZ and Piwi domains. Fluorescence microscopy revealed that the overexpressed C-terminal GFP-fusion of PAZ-PiwiAgnA (PPWa-GFP) localized to the cytoplasm. Overexpression of PPWa-GFP leaded to an increased gene silencing efficiency mediated by RNAi but not by antisense RNA. This indicated that PAZ-PiwiAgnA is involved in the RNAi pathway, but not in the antisense pathway. An analysis of protein-protein interactions by a yeast-two-hybrid screen on a cDNA library from vegetatively grown Dictyostelium revealed that several proteins, such as EF2, EF1-I, IfdA, SahA, SamS, RANBP1, UAE1, CapA, and GpdA could interact with PAZ-PiwiAgnA. There was no interaction between PAZ-PiwiAgnA and HP1, HelF and DnmA detected by direct yeast-two-hybrid analysis. The fluorescence microscopy images showed that the overexpressed GFP-SahA or IfdA fusion proteins localized to both cytoplasm and nuclei, while the overexpressed GFP-SamS localized to the cytoplasm. The expression of SamS in AgnA knock down mutants was strongly down regulated on cDNA and mRNA level in, while the expression of SahA was only slightly down regulated. AgnA knock down mutants displayed defects in growth and phagocytosis, which suggested that AgnA affects also cell biological features. The inhibition of DNA methylation on DIRS-1 and Skipper retroelements, as well as the endogenous mvpB and telA gene, observed for the same strains, revealed that AgnA is involved in the DNA methylation pathway. Northern blot analysis showed that Skipper and DIRS-1 were rarely expressed in Ax2, but the expression of Skipper was upregulated in AgnA knock down mutants, while the expression of DIRS-1 was not changed. A knock out of the agnA gene failed even though the homologous recombination of the disruption construct occurred at the correct site, which indicated that there was a duplication of the agnA gene in the genome. The same phenomenon was also observed in ifdA knock out experiments.

Characterization of DnmA, the Dnmt2 homolog in Dictyostelium discoideum

Eukaryotic DNA m5C methyltransferases (MTases) play a major role in many epigenetic regulatory processes like genomic imprinting, X-chromosome inactivation, silencing of transposons and gene expression. Members of the two DNA m5C MTase families, Dnmt1 and Dnmt3, are relatively well studied and many details of their biological functions, biochemical properties as well as interaction partners are known. In contrast, the biological functions of the highly conserved Dnmt2 family, which appear to have non-canonical dual substrate specificity, remain enigmatic despite the efforts of many researchers. The genome of the social amoeba Dictyostelium encodes Dnmt2-homolog, the DnmA, as the only DNA m5C MTase which allowed us to study Dnmt2 function in this organism without interference by the other enzymes. The dnmA gene can be easily disrupted but the knock-out clones did not show obvious phenotypes under normal lab conditions, suggesting that the function of DnmA is not vital for the organism. It appears that the dnmA gene has a low expression profile during vegetative growth and is only 5-fold upregulated during development. Fluorescence microscopy indicated that DnmA-GFP fusions were distributed between both the nucleus and cytoplasm with some enrichment in nuclei. Interestingly, the experiments showed specific dynamics of DnmA-GFP distribution during the cell cycle. The proteins colocalized with DNA in the interphase and were mainly removed from nuclei during mitosis. DnmA functions as an active DNA m5C MTase in vivo and is responsible for weak but detectable DNA methylation of several regions in the Dictyostelium genome. Nevertheless, gel retardation assays showed only slightly higher affinity of the enzyme to dsDNA compared to ssDNA and no specificity towards various sequence contexts, although weak but detectable specificity towards AT-rich sequences was observed. This could be due to intrinsic curvature of such sequences. Furthermore, DnmA did not show denaturant-resistant covalent complexes with dsDNA in vitro, although it could form covalent adducts with ssDNA. Low binding and methyltransfer activity in vitro suggest the necessity of additional factor in DnmA function. Nevertheless, no candidates could be identified in affinity purification experiments with different tagged DnmA fusions. In this respect, it should be noted that tagged DnmA fusion preparations from Dictyostelium showed somewhat higher activity in both covalent adduct formation and methylation assays than DnmA expressed in E.coli. Thus, the presence of co-purified factors cannot be excluded. The low efficiency of complex formation by the recombinant enzyme and the failure to define interacting proteins that could be required for DNA methylation in vivo, brought up the assumption that post-translational modifications could influence target recognition and enzymatic activity. Indeed, sites of phosphorylation, methylation and acetylation were identified within the target recognition domain (TRD) of DnmA by mass spectrometry. For phosphorylation, the combination of MS data and bioinformatic analysis revealed that some of the sites could well be targets for specific kinases in vivo. Preliminary 3D modeling of DnmA protein based on homology with hDNMT2 allowed us to show that several identified phosphorylation sites located on the surface of the molecule, where they would be available for kinases. The presence of modifications almost solely within the TRD domain of DnmA could potentially modulate the mode of its interaction with the target nucleic acids. DnmA was able to form denaturant-resistant covalent intermediates with several Dictyostelium tRNAs, using as a target C38 in the anticodon loop. The formation of complexes not always correlated with the data from methylation assays, and seemed to be dependent on both sequence and structure of the tRNA substrate. The pattern, previously suggested by the Helm group for optimal methyltransferase activity of hDNMT2, appeared to contribute significantly in the formation of covalent adducts but was not the only feature of the substrate required for DnmA and hDNMT2 functions. Both enzymes required Mg2+ to form covalent complexes, which indicated that the specific structure of the target tRNA was indispensable. The dynamics of covalent adduct accumulation was different for DnmA and different tRNAs. Interestingly, the profiles of covalent adduct accumulation for different tRNAs were somewhat similar for DnmA and hDNMT2 enzymes. According to the proposed catalytic mechanism for DNA m5C MTases, the observed denaturant-resistant complexes corresponded to covalent enamine intermediates. The apparent discrepancies in the data from covalent complex formation and methylation assays may be interpreted by the possibility of alternative pathways of the catalytic mechanism, leading not to methylation but to exchange or demethylation reactions. The reversibility of enamine intermediate formation should also be considered. Curiously, native gel retardation assays showed no or little difference in binding affinities of DnmA to different RNA substrates and thus the absence of specificity in the initial enzyme binding. The meaning of the tRNA methylation as well as identification of novel RNA substrates in vivo should be the aim of further experiments.

Biologische Funktionsanalyse und Identifizierung neuer Substrate der Methyltransferase Dnmt2

Obwohl die DNA Methyltransferase 2 (Dnmt2) hoch konserviert ist und zu der am weitesten verbreiteten eukaryotischen MTase-Familie gehört, ist ihre biologische Funktion nach wie vor unklar. Nachdem lange Zeit keine DNA Methylierungsaktivität nachgewiesen werden konnte, wurde vor einigen Jahren über geringe Mengen an 5-Methylcytosin (5mC) in Retroelementen der “Dnmt2-only”-Organismen D. melanogaster, D. discoideum und E. histolytica berichtet (Kunert et al. 2003; Fisher et al. 2004; Kuhlmann et al. 2005; Phalke et al. 2009). Als kurze Zeit später robuste Methylierung der tRNAAsp durch humane Dnmt2 gezeigt wurde (Goll et al. 2006), wurde zunächst eine Dualspezifität des Enzyms vorgeschlagen (Jeltsch et al. 2006). Neuere Daten zum 5mC-Status verschiedener „Dnmt2-only“-Organismen bilden Anlass für kontroverse Diskussionen über Ausmaß und Bedeutung der DNA Methyltransferaseaktivität von Dnmt2 (Schaefer et al. 2010a; Krauss et al. 2011). Die vorliegende Arbeit konzentriert sich auf die Identifizierung neuer RNA Substrate des Dnmt2-Homologs DnmA aus D. discoideum sowie die biologische Bedeutung der tRNA-Methylierung durch Dnmt2. Wie in anderen Organismen beschrieben, fungiert auch DnmA als tRNAAsp(GUC) MTase in vitro und in vivo. Zusätzlich konnte in vitro tRNAGlu(UUC) als neues Substrat der Dnmt2-Homologe aus D. discoideum und dem Menschen identifiziert werden. In einem Kooperationsprojekt wurde außerdem auch tRNAAsp-Methylierungsaktivität für das Dnmt2-Homolog aus S. pombe (Pmt1) nachgewiesen. Crosslink-RNA-Immunopräzipitationen (RNA-CLIP) mit anschließender Next-Generation-Sequenzierung der mit DnmA assoziierten RNAs zeigen, dass DnmA mit tRNA Fragmenten interagiert, die sich vom Anticodonloop bis in den T-loop erstrecken. Neben der tRNAAsp(GUC) und tRNAGlu(UUC/CUC) sind Fragmente der tRNAGly(GCC) verstärkt angereichert. Inwiefern diese Fragmente eine biologische Funktion haben oder spezifische Degradationsprodukte darstellen, ist noch ungeklärt. Interessanterweise sind von einigen tRNAs wenige Sequenzen von antisense-Fragmenten in den RNA-CLIP Daten zu finden, die etwas kürzer, jedoch exakt komplementär zu den genannten sense-Fragmenten sind. Besonders stark sind diese Fragmente der tRNAGlu(UUC) vertreten. In einem weiteren RNA-CLIP Experiment wurden U-snRNAs, snoRNA und intergenische Sequenzen mit DnmA angereichert. Bei nachfolgenden in vitro Methylierungsstudien konnte ausschließlich die U2-snRNA als potentielles Nicht-tRNA-Substrat der hDnmt2 und DnmA identifiziert werden. Da tRNA Modifikationen im Anticodonloop die Codonerkennung beeinflussen können, wurde ein System etabliert um die Translationseffizienz eines GFP-Reportergens in Wildtyp- und dnmAKO-Zellen zu messen. In D. discoideum wird das Aspartat-Codon GAU ca. zehnmal häufiger genutzt als das GAC Codon, allerdings ist nur eine tRNAAsp(GUC) im Genom der Amöbe kodiert. Aus diesem Grund wurde zusätzlich die Frage adressiert, inwiefern die DnmA-abhängige Methylierung dieser tRNA das „Wobbling“ beeinflusst. Dazu wurde dem Reportergen jeweils eine (GAU)5- und (GAC)5-Leadersequenz vorgeschaltet. Entgegen der Annahme wurde der (GAC)5-Leader in beiden Stämmen etwas effizienter translatiert. Insgesamt zeigte der dnmAKO-Stamm eine leicht erhöhte Translationseffizienz der Reportergene. Vergleichende Analysen zur Aufnahme von Fremd-DNA zeigten signifikant reduzierte Transformationseffizienzen mit einem integrierenden Plasmid in dnmAKO-Zellen. Ein weiterer dnmAKO-Stamm zeigte diesen Effekt jedoch nicht, wobei bei derselben Mutante eine deutlich reduzierte Aufnahme eines extrachromosomalen Plasmids zu verzeichnen war. Untersuchungen zum Einfluss von DnmA auf die Regulation des Retroelements skipper ergaben keinen Zusammenhang zwischen der Generierung kleiner RNAs und der erhöhten Transkription des Retrotransposons in dnmAKO-Zellen (Kuhlmann et al. 2005). Durch Kompensationsversuche sowie Experimente mit einer weiteren dnmAKO-Mutante konnte die Mobilisierung des Retrotransposons nicht eindeutig als DnmA-Funktion eingeordnet werden. In einem weiteren Projekt wurden die Bindung des m5C-bindenden Proteins EhMLBP aus E. histolytica an DNA mittels Rasterkraftmikroskopie abgebildet (Lavi et al. 2006). Neben vermutlich unspezifischen Endbindungsereignissen konnte eine bevorzugte Bindungsstelle des Proteins an LINE DNA (long intersperesed nuclear element) identifiziert werden. Möglicherweise fällt diese mit einem von zwei A/T-reichen Bereichen der LINE DNA zusammen, von denen vermutet wird, dass diese für die Bindung von EhMLBP an DNA von Bedeutung sind. Insgesamt bestätigen die Ergebnisse dieser Arbeit die tRNAAsp Methylierungsaktivität als konservierte Dnmt2-Funktion. Darüber hinaus erweitern sie das Substratspektrum der Dnmt2-Methyltransferasen im Bereich der tRNA. Außerdem wird erstmals ein potentielles Nicht-tRNA Substrat vorgeschlagen. Zusätzlich geben neu entdeckte Phänotypen Hinweise auf vielfältige zelluläre Dnmt2-Funktionen.